|
|
CSE300 Multimedia Systems: Student Work
Charts of Results
Threshold Varying Analysis (256x256 Lena, D4 Wavelet, YCbCr, 4:2:0)
|
YCbCr |
RGB |
| Threshold |
MSE |
NMSE |
SNR |
PSNR |
MSE |
NMSE |
SNR |
PSNR |
% Zeros |
| 5 |
5.702 |
0.024 |
16.181 |
33.010 |
12.682 |
0.052 |
12.834 |
26.066 |
82.630 |
| 10 |
5.856 |
0.024 |
16.065 |
32.779 |
12.736 |
0.052 |
12.815 |
26.029 |
87.852 |
| 15 |
6.105 |
0.0257 |
15.884 |
32.415 |
13.060 |
0.053 |
12.706 |
25.811 |
90.346 |
| 20 |
6.386 |
0.0269 |
15.688 |
32.024 |
13.474 |
0.0553 |
12.571 |
25.540 |
91.869 |
| 25 |
6.678 |
0.0282 |
15.494 |
31.637 |
13.924 |
0.0571 |
12.428 |
25.255 |
92.939 |
| 30 |
6.963 |
0.0294 |
15.313 |
31.274 |
14.381 |
0.0590 |
12.288 |
24.974 |
93.740 |
| 35 |
7.229 |
0.0305 |
15.150 |
30.948 |
14.818 |
0.0608 |
12.158 |
24.714 |
94.358 |
| 40 |
7.476 |
0.0315 |
15.004 |
30.656 |
15.225 |
0.0625 |
12.040 |
24.479 |
94.850 |
| 45 |
7.721 |
0.0326 |
14.864 |
30.376 |
15.639 |
0.0642 |
11.924 |
24.246 |
95.269 |
| 50 |
7.950 |
0.0336 |
14.737 |
30.112 |
16.023 |
0.0657 |
11.818 |
24.035 |
95.617 |
| 75 |
8.955 |
0.0378 |
14.220 |
29.089 |
17.751 |
0.0728 |
11.373 |
23.146 |
96.728 |
| 100 |
9.737 |
0.0411 |
13.856 |
28.361 |
19.104 |
0.0784 |
11.054 |
22.508 |
97.344 |
| 125 |
10.382 |
0.0438 |
13.578 |
27.805 |
20.252 |
0.0831 |
10.801 |
22.001 |
97.740 |
| 150 |
10.863 |
0.0459 |
13.381 |
27.411 |
21.117 |
0.0866 |
10.619 |
21.638 |
98.012 |
| 175 |
11.267 |
0.0476 |
13.223 |
27.094 |
21.860 |
0.0897 |
10.469 |
21.337 |
98.219 |
| 200 |
11.641 |
0.0491 |
13.081 |
26.810 |
22.529 |
0.0924 |
10.338 |
21.075 |
98.385 |
| 300 |
12.950 |
0.0547 |
12.618 |
25.885 |
24.938 |
0.1023 |
9.897 |
20.193 |
98.835 |
| 400 |
13.910 |
0.0587 |
12.307 |
25.263 |
26.696 |
0.1096 |
9.601 |
19.601 |
99.050 |
| 500 |
14.749 |
0.0623 |
12.053 |
24.755 |
28.262 |
0.1160 |
9.354 |
19.106 |
99.198 |
(256x256 Lena, 8x8 DCT, RGB, 4:2:0)
|
RGB |
RGB |
| Quality |
MSE |
NMSE |
SNR |
PSNR |
MSE |
NMSE |
SNR |
PSNR |
% Zeros |
| 0 |
74.788 |
0.3070 |
5.1279 |
10.654 |
74.788 |
0.3070 |
5.1279 |
10.654 |
99.820 |
| 5 |
43.341 |
0.1779 |
7.4971 |
15.392 |
43.341 |
0.1779 |
7.4971 |
15.392 |
97.728 |
| 10 |
35.039 |
0.1438 |
8.4206 |
17.239 |
35.039 |
0.1438 |
8.4206 |
17.239 |
96.178 |
| 15 |
32.183 |
0.1321 |
8.7899 |
17.978 |
32.183 |
0.1321 |
8.7899 |
17.978 |
94.798 |
| 20 |
30.492 |
0.1251 |
9.0243 |
18.447 |
30.492 |
0.1251 |
9.0243 |
18.447 |
93.764 |
| 25 |
29.205 |
0.1199 |
9.2116 |
18.821 |
29.205 |
0.1199 |
9.2116 |
18.821 |
92.909 |
| 30 |
28.064 |
0.1152 |
9.3846 |
19.167 |
28.064 |
0.1152 |
9.3846 |
19.167 |
92.168 |
| 35 |
27.007 |
0.1108 |
9.5514 |
19.501 |
27.007 |
0.1108 |
9.5514 |
19.501 |
91.538 |
| 40 |
26.068 |
0.1070 |
9.7050 |
19.808 |
26.068 |
0.1070 |
9.7050 |
19.808 |
91.020 |
| 45 |
25.109 |
0.1030 |
9.8677 |
20.133 |
25.109 |
0.1030 |
9.8677 |
20.133 |
90.433 |
| 50 |
24.362 |
0.1000 |
9.9990 |
20.396 |
24.362 |
0.1000 |
9.9990 |
20.396 |
90.012 |
| 55 |
23.502 |
0.0964 |
10.155 |
20.708 |
23.502 |
0.0964 |
10.155 |
20.708 |
89.309 |
| 60 |
22.586 |
0.0927 |
10.327 |
21.053 |
22.586 |
0.0927 |
10.327 |
21.053 |
88.640 |
| 65 |
21.606 |
0.0887 |
10.520 |
21.439 |
21.606 |
0.0887 |
10.520 |
21.439 |
87.854 |
| 70 |
20.546 |
0.0843 |
10.738 |
21.876 |
20.546 |
0.0843 |
10.738 |
21.876 |
86.896 |
| 75 |
19.428 |
0.0797 |
10.981 |
22.362 |
19.428 |
0.0797 |
10.981 |
22.362 |
85.723 |
| 80 |
18.118 |
0.0743 |
11.285 |
22.968 |
18.118 |
0.0743 |
11.285 |
22.968 |
83.882 |
| 85 |
16.736 |
0.0687 |
11.629 |
23.657 |
16.736 |
0.0687 |
11.629 |
23.657 |
81.512 |
| 90 |
15.306 |
0.0628 |
12.017 |
24.433 |
15.306 |
0.0628 |
12.017 |
24.433 |
77.765 |
| 95 |
14.112 |
0.0579 |
12.370 |
25.138 |
14.112 |
0.0579 |
12.370 |
25.138 |
70.497 |
(256x256 Lena, 8x8 DCT, YCbCr, 4:2:0)
|
RGB |
RGB |
| Quality |
MSE |
NMSE |
SNR |
PSNR |
MSE |
NMSE |
SNR |
PSNR |
% Zeros |
| 0 |
52.845 |
0.2232 |
6.5113 |
13.670 |
97.346 |
0.3996 |
3.9830 |
8.3644 |
99.900 |
| 5 |
26.698 |
0.1128 |
9.4765 |
19.600 |
50.923 |
0.2090 |
6.7970 |
13.992 |
98.293 |
| 10 |
19.977 |
0.0844 |
10.736 |
22.120 |
38.337 |
0.1573 |
8.0299 |
16.458 |
96.805 |
| 15 |
16.490 |
0.0696 |
11.569 |
23.786 |
31.926 |
0.1310 |
8.8246 |
18.047 |
95.581 |
| 20 |
14.874 |
0.0628 |
12.017 |
24.682 |
28.881 |
0.1185 |
9.2600 |
18.918 |
94.729 |
| 25 |
14.045 |
0.0593 |
12.266 |
25.180 |
27.374 |
0.1123 |
9.4927 |
19.383 |
94.014 |
| 30 |
13.265 |
0.0560 |
12.514 |
25.676 |
25.889 |
0.1062 |
9.7349 |
19.868 |
93.348 |
| 35 |
12.741 |
0.0538 |
12.689 |
26.026 |
24.897 |
0.1022 |
9.9046 |
20.207 |
92.781 |
| 40 |
12.377 |
0.0522 |
12.815 |
26.278 |
24.194 |
0.0993 |
10.029 |
20.456 |
92.298 |
| 45 |
11.956 |
0.0505 |
12.965 |
26.578 |
23.357 |
0.0958 |
10.182 |
20.762 |
91.752 |
| 50 |
11.657 |
0.0492 |
13.075 |
26.798 |
22.806 |
0.0936 |
10.285 |
20.969 |
91.415 |
| 55 |
11.245 |
0.0475 |
13.231 |
27.111 |
21.977 |
0.0902 |
10.446 |
21.291 |
90.873 |
| 60 |
10.853 |
0.0458 |
13.385 |
27.419 |
21.220 |
0.0871 |
10.598 |
21.595 |
90.341 |
| 65 |
10.260 |
0.0433 |
13.629 |
27.907 |
20.062 |
0.0823 |
10.842 |
22.083 |
89.655 |
| 70 |
9.5977 |
0.0405 |
13.919 |
28.487 |
18.778 |
0.0770 |
11.129 |
22.657 |
88.929 |
| 75 |
8.9095 |
0.0376 |
14.242 |
29.133 |
17.402 |
0.0714 |
11.460 |
23.318 |
88.056 |
| 80 |
8.0365 |
0.0339 |
14.690 |
30.029 |
15.657 |
0.0642 |
11.919 |
24.236 |
86.640 |
| 85 |
7.1091 |
0.0300 |
15.223 |
31.094 |
13.790 |
0.0566 |
12.470 |
25.339 |
85.015 |
| 90 |
6.0386 |
0.0255 |
15.932 |
32.512 |
11.698 |
0.0480 |
13.185 |
26.768 |
82.341 |
| 95 |
4.5542 |
0.0192 |
17.157 |
34.962 |
8.7914 |
0.0360 |
14.425 |
29.249 |
76.662 |
(256x256 Lena, 8x8 DCT, HSI, 4:2:0)
|
RGB |
RGB |
| Quality |
MSE |
NMSE |
SNR |
PSNR |
MSE |
NMSE |
SNR |
PSNR |
% Zeros |
| 0 |
68.905 |
0.2609 |
5.8350 |
11.365 |
136.71 |
0.5613 |
2.5079 |
5.4142 |
99.871 |
| 5 |
38.476 |
0.1456 |
8.3656 |
16.426 |
68.281 |
0.2803 |
5.5232 |
11.444 |
97.532 |
| 10 |
31.442 |
0.1190 |
9.2424 |
18.180 |
53.670 |
0.2203 |
6.5688 |
13.536 |
96.129 |
| 15 |
28.368 |
0.1074 |
9.6892 |
19.074 |
48.120 |
0.1975 |
7.0429 |
14.484 |
94.666 |
| 20 |
26.788 |
0.1014 |
9.9381 |
19.571 |
44.399 |
0.1822 |
7.3924 |
15.183 |
93.411 |
| 25 |
25.730 |
0.0974 |
10.113 |
19.921 |
42.534 |
0.1746 |
7.5788 |
15.555 |
92.561 |
| 30 |
24.942 |
0.0944 |
10.248 |
20.192 |
41.191 |
0.1691 |
7.7181 |
15.834 |
91.956 |
| 35 |
24.309 |
0.0920 |
10.359 |
20.415 |
40.153 |
0.1648 |
7.8290 |
16.056 |
91.489 |
| 40 |
23.820 |
0.0901 |
10.448 |
20.591 |
39.351 |
0.1615 |
7.9166 |
16.231 |
91.089 |
| 45 |
23.319 |
0.0883 |
10.540 |
20.776 |
38.500 |
0.1580 |
8.0115 |
16.421 |
90.643 |
| 50 |
22.899 |
0.0867 |
10.619 |
20.934 |
37.683 |
0.1547 |
8.1047 |
16.607 |
90.329 |
| 55 |
22.365 |
0.0846 |
10.721 |
21.139 |
37.139 |
0.1524 |
8.1678 |
16.734 |
89.844 |
| 60 |
21.750 |
0.0823 |
10.842 |
21.381 |
36.306 |
0.1490 |
8.2663 |
16.931 |
89.128 |
| 65 |
21.036 |
0.0796 |
10.987 |
21.671 |
35.169 |
0.1443 |
8.4045 |
17.207 |
88.271 |
| 70 |
20.197 |
0.0764 |
11.164 |
22.024 |
34.061 |
0.1398 |
8.5435 |
17.485 |
87.415 |
| 75 |
19.258 |
0.0729 |
11.371 |
22.438 |
32.878 |
0.1349 |
8.6971 |
17.792 |
86.368 |
| 80 |
18.173 |
0.0688 |
11.623 |
22.942 |
31.560 |
0.1295 |
8.8747 |
18.147 |
84.794 |
| 85 |
17.047 |
0.0645 |
11.900 |
23.497 |
29.881 |
0.1226 |
9.1121 |
18.622 |
82.657 |
| 90 |
15.909 |
0.0602 |
12.201 |
24.097 |
28.419 |
0.1166 |
9.3301 |
19.058 |
79.265 |
| 95 |
14.896 |
0.0564 |
12.486 |
24.668 |
27.214 |
0.1117 |
9.5182 |
19.434 |
72.855 |
(256x256 Lena, 8x8 DCT, Lab, 4:2:0)
|
RGB |
RGB |
| Quality |
MSE |
NMSE |
SNR |
PSNR |
MSE |
NMSE |
SNR |
PSNR |
% Zeros |
| 0 |
84.702 |
0.3443 |
4.6293 |
9.5728 |
238.05 |
0.9773 |
0.0994 |
0.5972 |
99.451 |
| 5 |
46.441 |
0.1888 |
7.2392 |
14.792 |
123.58 |
0.5073 |
2.9465 |
6.2913 |
96.168 |
| 10 |
42.769 |
0.1738 |
7.5970 |
15.508 |
106.70 |
0.4381 |
3.5842 |
7.5668 |
94.856 |
| 15 |
38.974 |
0.1584 |
8.0005 |
16.315 |
92.858 |
0.3812 |
4.1880 |
8.7743 |
92.717 |
| 20 |
36.745 |
0.1494 |
8.2563 |
16.826 |
87.363 |
0.3586 |
4.4529 |
9.3042 |
91.587 |
| 25 |
35.201 |
0.1431 |
8.4427 |
17.199 |
83.174 |
0.3414 |
4.6663 |
9.7310 |
90.846 |
| 30 |
33.013 |
0.1342 |
8.7213 |
17.756 |
84.542 |
0.3470 |
4.5955 |
9.5893 |
90.198 |
| 35 |
30.517 |
0.1240 |
9.0629 |
18.439 |
75.457 |
0.3097 |
5.0891 |
10.576 |
89.589 |
| 40 |
28.451 |
0.1156 |
9.3672 |
19.048 |
71.350 |
0.2929 |
5.3322 |
11.062 |
89.105 |
| 45 |
27.041 |
0.1099 |
9.5879 |
19.490 |
69.787 |
0.2865 |
5.4284 |
11.255 |
88.418 |
| 50 |
26.104 |
0.1061 |
9.7412 |
19.796 |
67.781 |
0.2782 |
5.5551 |
11.508 |
87.841 |
| 55 |
25.012 |
0.1016 |
9.9268 |
20.167 |
62.497 |
0.2565 |
5.9075 |
12.213 |
86.944 |
| 60 |
23.961 |
0.0974 |
10.113 |
20.540 |
58.085 |
0.2384 |
6.2255 |
12.849 |
86.375 |
| 65 |
23.223 |
0.0944 |
10.249 |
20.812 |
54.872 |
0.2252 |
6.4727 |
13.343 |
85.787 |
| 70 |
22.648 |
0.0920 |
10.358 |
21.030 |
52.963 |
0.2174 |
6.6264 |
13.651 |
85.102 |
| 75 |
21.846 |
0.0888 |
10.514 |
21.343 |
51.464 |
0.2112 |
6.7511 |
13.900 |
83.918 |
| 80 |
20.804 |
0.0845 |
10.726 |
21.767 |
47.451 |
0.1948 |
7.1037 |
14.605 |
81.858 |
| 85 |
19.496 |
0.0792 |
11.008 |
22.331 |
42.338 |
0.1738 |
7.5989 |
15.596 |
79.744 |
| 90 |
18.280 |
0.0743 |
11.288 |
22.890 |
35.859 |
0.1472 |
8.3201 |
17.038 |
76.572 |
| 95 |
17.394 |
0.0707 |
11.504 |
23.322 |
30.110 |
0.1236 |
9.0791 |
18.556 |
70.239 |
(256x256 Lena, 8x8 DCT, Luv, 4:2:0)
|
RGB |
RGB |
| Quality |
MSE |
NMSE |
SNR |
PSNR |
MSE |
NMSE |
SNR |
PSNR |
% Zeros |
| 0 |
101.46 |
0.3474 |
4.5910 |
8.0047 |
239.75 |
0.9843 |
0.0684 |
0.5352 |
99.460 |
| 5 |
68.385 |
0.2341 |
6.3044 |
11.431 |
129.79 |
0.5328 |
2.7336 |
5.8655 |
96.295 |
| 10 |
61.977 |
0.2122 |
6.7318 |
12.286 |
111.25 |
0.4567 |
3.4030 |
7.2043 |
94.790 |
| 15 |
58.843 |
0.2015 |
6.9571 |
12.736 |
99.000 |
0.4064 |
3.9098 |
8.2180 |
92.694 |
| 20 |
56.402 |
0.1931 |
7.1411 |
13.104 |
91.538 |
0.3758 |
4.2501 |
8.8986 |
91.621 |
| 25 |
54.692 |
0.1872 |
7.2748 |
13.372 |
86.864 |
0.3566 |
4.4778 |
9.3539 |
90.882 |
| 30 |
52.845 |
0.1809 |
7.4240 |
13.670 |
83.671 |
0.3435 |
4.6404 |
9.6792 |
90.238 |
| 35 |
51.189 |
0.1752 |
7.5623 |
13.947 |
80.768 |
0.3316 |
4.7938 |
9.9859 |
89.505 |
| 40 |
49.905 |
0.1708 |
7.6726 |
14.167 |
78.358 |
0.3217 |
4.9253 |
10.249 |
88.854 |
| 45 |
48.705 |
0.1667 |
7.7783 |
14.379 |
75.210 |
0.3087 |
5.1034 |
10.605 |
88.035 |
| 50 |
47.894 |
0.1640 |
7.8513 |
14.525 |
72.698 |
0.2984 |
5.2509 |
10.900 |
87.435 |
| 55 |
47.042 |
0.1610 |
7.9291 |
14.680 |
70.071 |
0.2876 |
5.4108 |
11.219 |
86.492 |
| 60 |
46.249 |
0.1583 |
8.0030 |
14.828 |
67.399 |
0.2767 |
5.5796 |
11.557 |
85.743 |
| 65 |
45.548 |
0.1559 |
8.0694 |
14.961 |
65.243 |
0.2678 |
5.7208 |
11.840 |
84.886 |
| 70 |
44.920 |
0.1538 |
8.1296 |
15.081 |
63.054 |
0.2588 |
5.8690 |
12.136 |
83.961 |
| 75 |
44.331 |
0.1518 |
8.1870 |
15.196 |
61.060 |
0.2506 |
6.0086 |
12.415 |
82.621 |
| 80 |
43.743 |
0.1497 |
8.2450 |
15.312 |
59.239 |
0.2432 |
6.1401 |
12.678 |
80.723 |
| 85 |
43.150 |
0.1477 |
8.3042 |
15.431 |
56.473 |
0.2318 |
6.3478 |
13.093 |
78.564 |
| 90 |
42.600 |
0.1458 |
8.3599 |
15.542 |
53.710 |
0.2205 |
6.5656 |
13.529 |
75.411 |
| 95 |
42.218 |
0.1445 |
8.3991 |
15.620 |
51.244 |
0.2103 |
6.7697 |
13.937 |
69.252 |
Last Modified: December 13, 1998
-
Barry E. Mapen
|